mojira.dev
MCPE-181269

Axe Always prioritizes scraping copper over shield

Summary

Same issue in MC-270047 (Was fixed in 24w18a Snapshot)

When holding an axe and holding a shield in your offhand, right clicking will prioritize scraping copper blocks (and I assume stripping logs) over blocking with your shield. 

Addons/Resource Packs: no
Attachments: yes

Steps to reproduce

  1. Take axe on mainhand and take shield on offhand

  2. Take waxed coppers and then place on line

  3. Sneak the player while blocking the shield and then right click/tap on target on axe

Observed Results

The axe are always prioritized to scrape copper while blocking the shield.

Expected Behavior

When a shield blocking in offhand, The axe do not always prioritized to scrape copper.

Attachments

Comments 2

Can confirm. But shield in Bedrock Edition is activated through sneaking, as such this would not have a big impact as in Java Edition?

There is no parity issue here. The issue described in the Java report arises because offhand shield use and main hand item use are done by pressing the same button. In Java that causes a gameplay issue when trying to block with the shield in trial chambers. That gameplay issue does not occur in Bedrock because in Bedrock the offhand shield and main hand item are already controlled by different inputs.

As I have told you before, please do not blindly copy Java bug reports to Bedrock without considering pre-existing differences between the Editions.

JervieA20

(Unassigned)

Community Consensus

Multiple

items, player, vanilla-parity

1.21.0.24 Preview

Retrieved